An Open Letter to Paula Deen

by Wednesday, January 18, 2012
0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 LinkedIn 0 Google+ 0 Email -- Buffer 0 0 Flares ×

Dear Paula,

I usually use this space to write about social media, but today I feel compelled to write a letter to you.

I should probably begin this letter by telling you that I have never watched your show.  It’s nothing against you, The Food Network, or Southerners (and I’m a transplanted Georgian myself)… I just don’t really enjoy cooking and never have.  That’s what happens when you are surrounded by picky eaters.

About 5 years ago, my daughter (who was 10 at the time) told me she had watched your show after eating at your restaurant during a Girl Scout trip to Savannah.  She said, “I like her because she eats her own food while she cooks.”  Beyond that conversation, you have not figured much in my life or my thought processes.  Again, it’s not anything personal.  We travel in different circles, and that’s okay.  You’ve never heard of me either.

Then yesterday, I watched Al Roker interview you on the Today Show, and I have to tell you that it really bothered me.

First of all, let me tell you that I’m truly sorry you have diabetes.  I applaud you for admitting it, having a positive outlook, and coming forward.

But here’s where I started to get angry.  You knew about this 3 years ago.  Really?  3 YEARS?  Why did you wait so long to tell the world?  Granted, I totally understand if you didn’t want to talk at first… after all, this is your personal health and it’s a private matter.  It’s not like you are President of the United States.  The health of one woman from Savannah doesn’t affect us much.

Or does it?

Paula, what bothered me is that you waited until you had a deal with a drug company to announce your condition.  And during that three year period from diagnosis to announcement, you continued to film cooking shows, showing an already overweight USA how to make even more fattening, heart-attack inducing dishes.  You were seeking medical treatment for your own condition, and yet you continued your own personal contribution to America’s obesity crisis.

Granted, I’ve heard your son has a cooking show where he teaches people how to take your butter-laden recipes, and make them more healthy.  I’ve also heard that you appear on his show and are very supportive.  That’s great.  But his show is NOT your show.  I’m sure he’s wonderful, but YOU are the real commodity here.  I’m sure you’ve heard a lot of people saying “well, it’s no wonder she got diabetes, the way she cooks and eats”.  I agree when you say, “what people see me doing and saying on TV is a very small portion of my life.  Nobody can or should eat like that all the time.”  It’s probably not fair for us to judge you based on such a small window into your life. Every month I need about 10 tablets of Cialis. Their price in the local pharmacies is rather high, so I always order the drugs from www.fitbell.com/how-does-cialis-help-men/. It saves my time, money, and helps avoid an awkward talk with the pharmacist. Overall, if you want to buy quality ED drugs without overpaying, check this site, I think it will be helpful.

But would it kill you to say, “I don’t know if I got this through my lifestyle or through genetics, but just to be on the safe side, I’m going to do better.  I owe it to myself.”  Think of how many people could have been spared the beginnings of major health problems and been inspired by you, if 3 years ago you had announced, “I have Type II Diabetes, and from now on, I plan to eat more healthy and live a healthy lifestyle.”  There could have been a whole movement of people who said, “If Paula can give up the fattening stuff, then so can I!”

Yes, I read in USA Today that you cut out your sweetened tea and use the treadmill on a daily basis.  That’s a very small start, but if you talked to most any endocrinologist, I guarantee you they would tell you, “that’s really not enough.”

Our country is in an obesity epidemic.  You have the chance to be a leader, a role model.  Why aren’t you taking it?  I’m sure Christopher Reeve didn’t want to be a role model either, but goodness knows he did it with dignity and grace.  When Al Roker asked you if you were going to start eating better and shape up, your response floored me.  It was something to the effect of, “This is entertainment.  People have to take care of themselves.  Honey, I’m your cook, not your doctor.”  Of course, you did say more than that, so to be fair, here is a link so people can watch the interview themselves.

Wrong, Paula Deen.  People’s health is NOT entertainment.  Not being able to catch your breath when you walk up the stairs is not entertaining.  Kids being bullied in school because they are overweight is NOT entertainment.  Getting insulin shots on a daily basis is NOT entertaining.  People having to purchase two seats on an airplane for one person, or people having to be buried in over-size coffins… that is NOT entertainment.  America’s obesity is rising, and is putting an unfair burden on our healthcare system.

In your interview, you kept talking about people needing to get treatment.  How about encouraging people to never put themselves at risk for diabetes at all?  Many cases are preventable. Whether it happened this way or not, the fact that you waited until you could announce your deal with the drug company along with your diagnosis really makes you look very greedy.  (And sorry, I’m not aware of Al being a paid spokesperson for another company, but you cannot compare the fact that you are being compensated for this to Al being compensated to report the weather and say, “Sunday, SUNDAY!!!”)

You have the opportunity to use your celebrity for good.  I’m begging you to take it.  Show America that you can do better, and they should too.

24 Responses
  • Mary Nadler
    January 18, 2012

    Wow, Karen, I think you said it all. I was thinking the same thing when I heard it and then I was watching CNN and heard them talking about it. I so appreciate you saying what a lot of people are feeling too. 

    • karen
      January 18, 2012

      Thank you Mary! Part of me thinks, who cares… I don’t watch her and it’s not my concern. But her actions just felt very hypocritical, and I couldn’t keep my mouth shut!

    • ProjectSocial
      January 18, 2012

      Thank you Mary! Part of me thinks, who cares… I don’t watch her and
      it’s not my concern. But her actions just felt very hypocritical, and I
      couldn’t keep my mouth shut!

  • Jamie Turner
    January 18, 2012

    I love this idea — a letter to Paula Deen. Bravo! Keep up the great posts.

    • karen
      January 18, 2012

      Thanks Jamie, as you know, I’ve been on a soap box about this for the last 2 days. The positive response I’m getting lets me know that I’m not alone in these feelings. Of course, Paula could always accept your offer for branding training:

    • ProjectSocial
      January 18, 2012

      Thanks Jamie, as you know, I’ve been on a soap box about this for the
      last 2 days. The positive response I’m getting lets me know that I’m
      not alone in these feelings. Of course, Paula could always accept your
      offer for branding training: http://60secondmarketer.com/blog/2012/01/17/paula-deen-offered-brand-management-training-by-branding-expert/

  • Aorphan2
    January 19, 2012

    Yes, she disclosed her diabetes in a tacky way but when I want to indulge, I may make Paula’s pumpkin goo bars and have one – not ten. She puts forth the recipes- it is up to everyone to practice self control.

    • ProjectSocial
      January 19, 2012

      Of course, Paula is not forcing anybody to eat anything.  And yes, those pumpkin goo bars do seem delicious.  Unfortunately, not everybody has self control, which is why our country is in an obesity crisis.  Just watching Jamie Oliver’s show (when he was in West Virginia) showed me a disturbing slice of life that I had never seen… and Huntington, WV is my hometown.  There is an appalling lack of knowledge out there, and Paula can make a difference by being a good role model.

  • Pete Warnock
    January 19, 2012

    If she didn’t cook like that, she wouldn’t be the celebrity she is, so she wouldn’t have any authority to lead people to healthier eating.  She never makes the claim that she’s cooking healthy, so she shouldn’t have any responsibility for the health of others.  It’s unfortunate that she has that disease.  However, her show is entertaining—even if I never eat her food.

    • ProjectSocial
      January 19, 2012

      Hi Pete, I completely agree that she is entertaining and doesn’t claim to be cooking healthy recipes.  And of course, she isn’t responsible for what people put in their mouths.  But I disagree that she has no authority… that’s like saying that Jennifer Hudson isn’t a good spokesperson for Weight Watchers, just because she USED to be fat.  Paula could set a good example for her fans for how things could and should be.

      • Lynn
        July 10, 2012

        You can talk to people till your blue in the face and tell them all the things they should do responsibly, like their eating habits, drinking habits, lifestyle habits, but until a person makes up their minds to do something about their specific problems it will fall on deaf ears.  I see where you were trying to go with your stance, but all the criticizm you are throwing out comes with a very negative approach.  We all could do better with our influence on other people’s lives, but we can’t be held accountable for their actions.

  • Wildonva
    January 19, 2012

    What bothers me most is the deal she made with the pharmaceutical company.  She can live her life as she pleases, and people can choose whether or not to use her recipes, but she shouldn’t profit off a hypocritical lifestyle.

    • ProjectSocial
      January 19, 2012

      Exactly, Laura.  As I said in this post, she waited THREE years until she had a deal to come out with this news.  It really does make her seem greedy and hypocritical.  She needs a new PR team.

  • Seleana Hobbs
    January 19, 2012

    Hi, I read your post and I am saddened to hear that Paula Dean has diabetes.  It’s an unfortunate disease that many Americans face but is completely preventable. Paula Dean’s cooking show is her business and it’s one of the ways that she makes money.  I do not agree that she should be held responsible for the health of others, however.   All of the butter and other fattening ingredients that she uses can be tweaked in many of the recipes by those who are health conscience. Just because the recipe says use 4 sticks of butter does not mean that you have to do so.  I think that we have to take responsibility for ourselves and our own health.   I can’t fault someone else for something I personally allowed to happen.   Just as some people say that singers, football & basketball players, and actors are role models to children, I disagree with that as well because as parents, we should be the first role model in teaching our children what is right vs. what is wrong. 
    Paula Dean’s diabetes diagnosis is something very personal and she shared it with everyone when she was comfortable talking about it.   I am not upset with her for taking a leadership role with a drug company to now teach people how to control and prevent the disease.  

    • ProjectSocial
      January 20, 2012

      Hi Seleana, I appreciate your thoughtful response.  This is what I love about blogging and social media… we can all express our opinions.

      I am not holding Paula responsible for the actions of others, and it would be great to think that most people realize they can (or should) substitute fatty ingredients for healthy ones.  Unfortunately, this is just not the case.  I remember watching Jamie Oliver’s Food Revolution when he went to my hometown (Huntington, WV), and was shocked at the way people fill their freezers with processed, fattening fast foods.  It’s people like this who watch her show and don’t realize there is a truly healthier way to eat.  (Or if they do know, they don’t know how to do it.)

      It’s people like this who could benefit from Paula saying, “Hey honey, you can use a stick of butter, or you could substitute it with a stick of fat-free margarine.”

  • Kharwood159
    January 21, 2012

    Dear People, 

    I love Paula Deen and hold no grudges against her food or her condition, even if it is a direct result of her cooking.  I grew up in the South, just as she did, and a lot of my recipes were handed down to me by my relatives and I cherish them and make them on a regular basis.  Sometimes I alter the fat, sugar & salt to make them more healthy and sometimes I don’t.  If you don’t overindulge then it will not kill you to have a bite every now and then.  
    Most of the time people go overboard on everything from drinking, drugging and eating, to name just a few.  It’s not until a problem surfaces that they try to do something about it and most often it takes a lot of time to commit to changing your habits and some never do.  But I guarantee you it is not because they were watching Paula Deen cooking with cream.  It was because it tasted good to them and they just did it. 
    We are all responsible for our actions.  You should not be so judgmental as to what someone should do so it fits neatly in your little box of what’s right and what’s not.  I admire her just as she is, butter and all.  

    • ProjectSocial
      January 21, 2012

      Again, thank you for another thoughtful response.  As I’ve said on a few of these comments, it’s not that I hold her responsible for every person who is eating too much.  I just think that now that she has her diagnosis and has released it to the public, she is in a unique position to challenge her fans to get healthy along with her.

      • Kharwood159
        January 21, 2012

        Give her a chance to do that.  She built a multi-million dollar empire based on her personality and her way of cooking.  This is an issue which any savvy business owner should carefully consider before revealing an illness which could potentially harm that empire.  And as a former business owner myself I can certainly identify with her dilemma.  So it took her three years to admit.  A little long but consider that she may have taken advice from the people surrounding her before making it public.  
        However, I bet she will alter some of the content of her show to reflect her health issue especially because of the criticism floating around out there.  Also, it should be apparent to everyone she has taken a positive step in becoming a new spokesperson for a diabetes drug.  She didn’t do this to help a pharmaceutical company.  She did this to show people she intends to address her diagnosis.  But that doesn’t mean she will do a complete reversal of her cooking style either.I mean really, how many people do you know that have high blood pressure and still use salt and eat whatever they want because they take their medication?  Every single one of the people I know with this condition do this and nobody says a word.  People are going to do what they are going to do period.  It remains to be seen how this will turn out but I’m a huge fan of hers and I’m standing behind her 100%.  Rome wasn’t built in a day.

  • Ylaen
    February 1, 2012

    As a long time fan of my girl paula’s show, not every show is about how much butter she can put in a dish.   Yes she makes rich food, but the obestity problem  in this country began long before anyone knew who Paula Dean was.  I think its our responsibilty and not a celebrity chefs job to make healthy food choices for us.  My mother taught how to be a healthy eater and make good choices with regards to food.  So I can watch Paula’s Best Dishes and take what I want from it.  I know that her recipes are part of every special occaion I have, whether its thanksgiving or christmas and i wouldn’t have it any other way

    • ProjectSocial
      February 3, 2012

      Hi Ylaen,

      Thanks for your message.  I completely agree that it is our responsibility as adults to make healthy food choices.  In an ideal way, that IS how things would work.  But I just think there are too many people watching Paula’s show who don’t realize that all of that butter (and other ingredients) might not be such a good idea.  She has a great opportunity to take the lead and run with it.  I really hope she will!

  • Constance Mitchell
    February 2, 2012

    Paula Deen is a hypocrite…a greedy one at that.  I will never watch her show again. Nor will I
    purchase any of her products.
    Every show, pushing all that food in her mouth, along with her sons at her side doing the same thing, – is just as encouraging us to do the same. SHAME on you PAULA DEan.

    Not only  is she a big hypocrite, but her sons are as well –  GREEDY to accept such a deal from a drug company at a time when she was going to announce to the world that she has T2 diabetes which she and them knew all along for over 3 years.

    Sadly, her PR was a complete disaster. She just coldn’t even say,…” I did not realize that I impact so many and I apologise to my followers.”  She went on tv and justified her attitude and talk about “moderation,”  “its all entertainment,” “I am your cook and not your doctor.”
    That is IRRESPONSIBILITY, folks.!!!

    With America’s obese problem, promoting her arterie-clogging, cooking, and foods she has been piling her mouth  on her show for years is unforgiveable because she promoted her shows as “these things are good for you, this is how you prepare them…”  while stuffing them in her mouth. Shame on her. She has let her fans down.  But Money talks!!!!

    • ProjectSocial
      February 3, 2012

      Hi Constance, thanks for your message.  Obviously, you and I are in agreement here!  Fortunately for Paula, the furor has died down and we’ve all moved on to the next big gripe.

  • Spitfirekat
    June 9, 2012

    hi paula i just want you to know i love watchen you.some of the things you cook make my mouth water.i wish i had you as a mom growing up.your like my hero in the kitchen.i love to get in there a come up with different dishes.i am holding on to one day meeting you but i have a new born so i am not going any were any time soon.im sorry about your diabetes.i had diabetes when i was careing both my girl.so i some what know what your going through.i just want you to know i really look up to you.and look forward to watchen your shows.hope things stay good for you and your family.i want to be able to cook as good as you one day

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 LinkedIn 0 Google+ 0 Email -- Buffer 0 0 Flares ×